Obligation and Defense regarding Reinstatement: Cassation File Number: 228917

   Date: October 30, 2015 (E.C.)    Binding Legal Interpretation (Principle):    After a termination is found to be unlawful, the employee has the right to be reinstated. Unless the employer specifically argues and proves reasons why the employee should not be reinstated (e.g., redundancy of the position), it is a fundamental error of law … Read more

Burden of Proof for Termination: Cassation File Number: 228116

   Date: October 29, 2015 (E.C.)    Binding Legal Interpretation (Principle): Where an employer argues that it has dismissed an employee, the occurrence of the termination itself cannot be a point of contention (issue). When an employer claims to have terminated the contract due to the employee’s fault (e.g., absenteeism), the employer bears the burden … Read more

Organizational Downsizing: Cassation File Number 228104

   Date: November 28, 2015 (E.C.)    Binding Legal Interpretation (Principle):        Criteria for Legality of Termination: When an employer terminates an employee due to organizational downsizing or weakened financial capacity pursuant to Article 28(1)(d) and 29 of Proclamation No. 1156/2011, the employer bears the burden of proving, through factual and scientific studies, that the … Read more

Permanent Closure of an Undertaking: Cassation Case No.: 235842

   Case No.: 235842    Date: January 31, 2023 (Tir 23, 2015 E.C.)    Legal Rule/Interpretation: When an organization is permanently closed due to bankruptcy or any other reason (pursuant to Article 24(4) of Proclamation No. 1156/2019), the employment contract may be terminated. The fundamental point to be verified is whether the employer’s organization has … Read more

Framing of Issues in Redundancy: Cassation Case No. 235721

   Case No.: 235721    Date: February 1, 2023 (Tir 24, 2015 E.C.)    Legal Rule/Interpretation: In labor disputes, courts are expected to frame and investigate relevant issues regarding the legality of a workforce reduction (redundancy) based on the pleadings of the parties and pursuant to Articles 28(3) and 29 of Proclamation No. 1156/2019. Framing … Read more

Execution of Reinstatement Decision: Cassation Case No.: 235541

 Case No.: 235541    Date: June 5, 2023 (Ginbot 28, 2015 E.C.)    Legal Rule/Interpretation: Where it has been established that an employer’s termination of an employment contract was unlawful and a decision has been rendered for the reinstatement of the employee, it is improper and restrictive of the employee’s rights to decide against reinstatement … Read more